Arguments for Emily/Lillian

[Hodge]

Mar 25, 2015 1:49:05 GMT snacky said:

Mar 24, 2015 20:47:08 GMT Hodge said:

Whether Lillian will be given a chance to be seen differently we'll only know after the next ep or beginning of the next season. Does she have a chance of redemption? Yes. Will she be redeemed? Only time will tell. I've changed my mind about characters in the past and the last couple of eps where she hasn't been able to put her foot in her mouth have calmed my nerves around her but it'll take quite a bit of taming that mouth to make me see her in a totally new light. Says me who's been spouting off on fb all day!

Oooh, what have you been spouting off about?

I've only revived the whole Lilliam issue because the idea that the storyline is driving George back to Emily is giving me the willies.

The direction the show is being taken.

[Miss Emily Grace]

Mar 15, 2015 17:11:40 GMT snacky said:

I was watching Loch Ness Murdoch last night, and I'm still amazed people were so forgiving of how rude Emily was to George. Remember how she just dumped his snowball gift in the sink? And later she invited him to leave and stole his snowball? This is one of the reasons I could never see "Gemily". But it also made it hard for me to get into Emily as a character because when she was with George she seemed rather mean-spirited.

I'm still not exactly in to Emily as a character: mainly it's going to take a while for other interesting character traits to make up for these earlier incidents. But I guess part of the reason I don't have a problem with Emily/Lillian is that I didn't see Emily as a particularly nice person in the first place. Therefore, the two inconsiderate young ladies seem to go together fine!

Looking forward to seeing what the writers do with this! Yes but Emily has been rude which is a character flaw like Lillian so I think that Emily & Lillian are perfect together xx