|
|
Post by murdochic on May 30, 2012 17:23:25 GMT
Julia has no reason to continue with the birth control thing she will be working for the police. I don't think William is remotely like Darcy and I can't see him being so judgemental about her personal beliefs. Plus, he wasn't bothered she was doing it anyway, he respected her stance. They are bound to clash over suspects though.
|
|
|
|
Post by petruck on May 30, 2012 20:28:44 GMT
Julia was incredibly passionate about her crusade to teaching women about birth control, it would be very sad if she suddenly dropped that. Also I never said Murdoch was anything like Darcy. What I was however implying was not that he would have a problem with what she was doing, but that his bosses certainly would (considering it is illegal,) and they both would have to learn to deal with it.
|
|
|
|
Post by hannikan on May 30, 2012 21:03:37 GMT
Darcy does want to divorce it seems but he very likely will be angry about what has happened in his relationship with Julia. And since no-fault divorce was not around, he will have to bring charges against her that would end the marriage. There was not yet a legal means to just part ways except get an annulment. That may be what they do in the end, but there will probably be some drama leading up to that. Annulments were really begun in the Catholic Church because the Catholic Church did not allow any type of divorce. So I don't think annulment would be Darcy and Julia's first inclination. I think it would be dropping the ball to not see Darcy again in S6. I'm not saying we need to see him throughout the whole season but we do need to have some more of him, I think.
Yeah, I hope they don't make Julia able to have children easily either. There should either be some difficulty or they should adopt first and then maybe she's able to after that. That happens quite a bit among couples who have trouble conceiving. They have trouble conceiving, so they adopt and then a few years later they are able to have a biological child. I don't think Julia will be running the birth control clinic now that she's becoming a psychiatrist. She wouldn't have time. But she and Emily may support it in some other way. They shouldn't let that plot completely drop. William probably wouldn't like it either because of the conflict with his religious beliefs but he wouldn't force her to stop for fear of repercussions to his career. Of course, William already knows he can't be promoted so he wouldn't worry about that anyway. And even though he knows the church opposes birth control, in addition to it being illegal, I think he understands Julia's point of view. He is beginning to understand that the law and the church are not right about everything and that changes to the law/doctrines must be made sometimes.
|
|
|
|
Post by murdochic on May 30, 2012 21:15:52 GMT
I can't see them rewriting Julia's infertility. It would be give more storyline scope if they do have to adopt. They'll have to discuss it again, and then they could always have how they get the child be a storyline connected to a crime. Though that couldn't be until the very late S6. As the marriage issue has to concluded before the child issue becomes one.
I am sure Julia and Emily will continue to campaign for birth control but Julia won't be a GP anymore so she wouldn't be directly involved in it like she was in S5. She will be like Emily was a campaigner which doesn't go against the law in anyway. As for William's religious beliefs he seemed to get over them in S5 so I don't see why he'd suddenly be against the idea in S6. Yes, he is very religious but those views are tempered by his social conscience and logical thinking. So he could see why birth control is a good idea, so that would override his religious beliefs. Like it's happened on various other things in the past. In the end he is always fair.
|
|
|
|
Post by catymurdoch on May 31, 2012 14:31:17 GMT
petruck, I think William is not too bothered about Julia's campaign about birth control. He just wants her to be careful and do it the right way and not being sent to jail. They probably could fight for birth control but just taking a another route, more legal and Julia could have William's support if she listens to him and she will listen to him like he always listens to her. On the romance side , I think they went out quite a lot, an on and off relationship but I think in season 3, they stayed together for a few months at least, close to one year, I would expect so they know each other well on the romantic side. But as they have been apart for 12 months because of the marriage, they need to take it a bit slow again but I think by the beginning of season 6, a few months would have passed already and we will see them very comfortable in their relationship.  |
|
|
|
Post by petunia on Jun 8, 2012 0:25:56 GMT
S6 being filmed right now. Other than a picture or two, I have not heard much. Has anobody syeen anything?
As for where Julia should work in S6. My preference would be for her to return to the morgue as the manager and add the profiling to her skillset. Doctors were mostly generalists in those days, so it would not be uncommon for her to do more than one specialty. I have yet to warm up to Dr. Grace, so i would not bothered if she left. If she has to stay then, I would prefer her to become Julia's assistant. Julia used to have assistants in S1 and S2. They disappeared in S3 and now she is always alone in the morgue.
I have posted this before but I will put it out there again. I really would like to see a catholic church scandal episode based in Montreal. William would have a big faith vs. dogma crisis. There are more than enough historical facts to draw from there.
Most of all, what I would like to see in S6 is continuity. I do not know how William went from being in love with Julia in S5e1 and S5E2 to smooching with Anna 5 episodes later and finally back in love with Julia in S5E11 and S5E13!!!
|
|
|
|
Post by barbarama on Jun 8, 2012 2:14:29 GMT
I haven't heard about season 6 at all except some articles about locations they are filming at, I am not sure that we will have much info until season 6 starts at the beginning of next year. As for your comment about Julia being back in the morgue and having Dr.Grace as her assistant I am not sure (as someone also posted before) that after being in charge of the morgue Dr.Grace would be relegated to being an assistant again and in my opinion even if Julia was a great pathologist I think Dr.Grace enjoy that field way more than Julia (she mentioned that on episode 2 of season 5). Julia wanted to heal the living that was one of the reason ("she said"  ) for considering the job in Buffalo, she also said she was questioning her calling in the episode "Hangman" in season 3. I think the reason she was happy to be back at the morgue in season 4 is because she wanted to work with William again, being close to him and debating case together that is why it comes as no surprise to me that she would want to work with him again and solve cases with him but as a psychiatrist this time. As for your comments about continuity I think William was always in love with Julia, the reason he was with Anna was because Julia was married and he felt that he needed to move on and he liked Anna he was just not in love with her so that is why he didn't go away with her. Those are just my opinions though, I am happy to discuss more about it because since the show stopped there is literally nothing as good as this on tv  |
|
|
|
Post by hannikan on Jun 8, 2012 5:00:24 GMT
Yeah, I feel the agree with you on those points, Barbara.
|
|
|
|
Post by barbarama on Jun 8, 2012 14:59:55 GMT
Thanks Hannikan for your comment Also Petunia, I think your idea about the church scandal is great, I would love to see that play out as well and it would definitely create conflicted feelings for William about the church and his faith |
|
|
|
Post by murdochic on Jun 10, 2012 17:27:33 GMT
bararama, you're right about William's feelings for Julia. He was never out of love with her. William made a decision in 501 to try and move on because Julia was married. And she made a decision in 502 to do the same when she quit the morgue. The Anna stuff was just him trying to move on and failing to do so. Because he has never been in love with Anna, which is why he never choose her in the end the three times she was around, and why he didn't go away with her. Which is why I will slap the writers if they bring her back for S6, there is definitely no role for her left with W/J an actual couple now. She is not needed for the spare part love interest once again.
I can't see W/J breaking up again next series. I think we will finally see them have a longterm relationships. Not without obstacles but nothing that will cause them to stall for a 3rd or 4th time. G/E are the new will-they-won't-they in town.
|
|
|
|
Post by barbarama on Jun 11, 2012 22:59:05 GMT
to Murdochic, I totally agree about the Anna thing, what is the point of bringing her back, obviously now that the Black Hand thinks she's dead what's the point of tempting fate and coming back to Toronto (unless she is so smitten by William that she has a dead wish ). They gave her another identity for her to live her life safely and I think that should be the end of it. I know other people mentioned that they wanted to have the Black Hand story again but personally I don't see the purpose; if they want to bring back a story with criminal then have Gillies coming back he was really creepy in "Murdoch in Toyland" and actually a fascinating/demented character!!! As for W/J I am on the same boat as you they better not breaking them up again it would make absolutely no sense and infuriate me to no end  !!! I think we can still have great stories with them being together as they don't always see eye to eye on things so it could create great banter and of course making up  |
|
|
|
Post by hannikan on Jun 12, 2012 0:21:09 GMT
As for W/J I am on the same boat as you they better not breaking them up again it would make absolutely no sense and infuriate me to no end !!! I think we can still have great stories with them being together as they don't always see eye to eye on things so it could create great banter and of course making up I agree that they can do a lot with them while they're together. I hope they do that instead of breaking them up again, too. If they bring Anna back I'm not worried about her coming between William and Julia. I think she does still have feelings for him and thinks he does for her. So she may come back. But I think he would make it clear that Julia is the only woman for him now. |
|
|
|
Post by murdochic on Jun 12, 2012 17:57:37 GMT
There is no reason for Anna to be brought back, she has no use in William's life and the Blackhand think she's dead. That storyline is over. She never was and never will be a risk to W/J so I wouldn't worry if she did come back. But she isn't needed for any of the storylines. She's as useless as Dr Roberts is these days.
If they want to resurrect the Blackhand they could have William, Julia and probably Emily as the new targets because they conned them. No need to have an outside character for that storyline.
|
|
|
|
Post by rondetto on Jun 19, 2012 17:21:58 GMT
If any of the visions William has had in previous episodes are to come to fruition, it could work out that he and Julia have a son, either naturally(Which looks unlikely) or adopted and move to the Yukon.
Only thing with that is it would mean not seeing Brackenreid and Crabtree agian, that would be a major loss as they're part of the
"family".
Still, I enjoy reading all your thoughts on upcoming story lines, keep em' coming.
|
|
|
|
Post by barbarama on Jun 20, 2012 1:05:18 GMT
The move to the Yukon is a nice idea but I know know what kind of mysteries would happen there However I hope Murdoch and Julia stay in Toronto and work at station 4 until at least season 10 or more!! (wishful thinking!!! ;D) |
|
) for considering the job in Buffalo, she also said she was questioning her calling in the episode "Hangman" in season 3. I think the reason she was happy to be back at the morgue in season 4 is because she wanted to work with William again, being close to him and debating case together that is why it comes as no surprise to me that she would want to work with him again and solve cases with him but as a psychiatrist this time. 
!!! I think we can still have great stories with them being together as they don't always see eye to eye on things so it could create great banter and of course making up 
