|
|
Post by fan2tvshows on Sept 20, 2014 23:53:33 GMT
Hello everybody! The great detective William MURDOCH, is he or is not he a virgin: that is the question.I read a lot of comments about this topic and as I think that we will surely have a clear-cut answer* to this question in the next season, I propose that you give a definitive answer; answer only based on the MURDOCH MYSTERIES TV show. However you must not leave a comment**, you just must answer by: - "William MURDOCH is a virgin". or - "William MURDOCH is not a virgin". Then later you will can say to others: "I knew it!".  *(At least I hope  . If William is still a virgin, it surely will be mentioned, won't it?  ). **(You can insert a smiley if you want to.  ). |
|
|
|
Post by fan2tvshows on Sept 20, 2014 23:53:50 GMT
William MURDOCH is a virgin.
|
|
|
|
Post by snacky on Sept 21, 2014 1:22:53 GMT
Hello everybody! The great detective William MURDOCH, is he or is not he a virgin: that is the question.I read a lot of comments about this topic and as I think that we will surely have a clear-cut answer* to this question in the next season, I propose that you give a definitive answer; answer only based on the MURDOCH MYSTERIES TV show. However you must not leave a comment**, you just must answer by: - "William MURDOCH is a virgin". or - "William MURDOCH is not a virgin". Then later you will can say to others: "I knew it!". *(At least I hope . If William is still a virgin, it surely will be mentioned, won't it? ). **(You can insert a smiley if you want to. ). I think you will be inspired and awed by FallenBelle's answer to this.  Ps. William is a virgin, though he's probably pushed the envelope of that quite a few times. I reserve the right to change my mind. I only changed it this week from Not a Virgin to Virgin. |
|
|
|
Post by fan2tvshows on Sept 21, 2014 2:19:00 GMT
Hello everybody! The great detective William MURDOCH, is he or is not he a virgin: that is the question.I read a lot of comments about this topic and as I think that we will surely have a clear-cut answer* to this question in the next season, I propose that you give a definitive answer; answer only based on the MURDOCH MYSTERIES TV show. However you must not leave a comment**, you just must answer by: - "William MURDOCH is a virgin". or - "William MURDOCH is not a virgin". Then later you will can say to others: "I knew it!". *(At least I hope . If William is still a virgin, it surely will be mentioned, won't it? ). **(You can insert a smiley if you want to. ). I think you will be inspired and awed by FallenBelle's answer to this. Ps. William is a virgin, though he's probably pushed the envelope of that quite a few times. I reserve the right to change my mind. I only changed it this week from Not a Virgin to Virgin. Please, no quotes and no comments! I know it's not easy  but play the game and just answer! |
|
|
|
Post by lovemondays on Sept 22, 2014 20:13:55 GMT
William Murdoch is NOT a virgin!
|
|
|
|
Post by ziggy on Sept 23, 2014 6:48:19 GMT
William Murdoch is NOT a virgin.
|
|
|
|
Post by mrsbrisby on Oct 1, 2014 6:10:11 GMT
William is a virgin.
|
|
|
|
Post by fan2tvshows on Oct 18, 2014 21:08:02 GMT
Hello! The wedding day is approaching...  Until now, five answers have been given: - 3 "William MURDOCH is a virgin". - 2 "William MURDOCH is not a virgin". Is there anybody else who would like to give his/her opinion? Read the rules in the presentation of this thread and just play the game!
|
|
robinzefrenchfan
New Member
Fan of "Les enquêtes de Murdoch - Murdoch Mysteries "
Posts: 5 
|
Post by robinzefrenchfan on Oct 18, 2014 21:27:19 GMT
Good evening everybody or Hello everybody,
This time I dare to write something. Forgive me if I make some mistakes in English I am really French.
On my opinion and according to the episodes I've watched on the french tv (france 3 on sunday evening) and also because Murdoch is Catholic and religious, I think he is a virgin.
He seems to be more conservative than Julia.
Of course I could be wrong.
Bye.
|
|
|
|
Post by snacky on Oct 18, 2014 21:50:35 GMT
Good evening everybody or Hello everybody, This time I dare to write something. Forgive me if I make some mistakes in English I am really French. On my opinion and according to the episodes I've watched on the french tv (france 3 on sunday evening) and also because Murdoch is Catholic and religious, I think he is a virgin. He seems to be more conservative than Julia. Of course I could be wrong. Bye. Bonjour! You are welcome here! Several people believe William is a virgin, and we love to argue over it! My friend who is a Catholic, though, does not believe religion would stand in his way. Could you explain more why being a Catholic would encourage William to remain a virgin? |
|
|
|
Post by mrsbrisby on Oct 19, 2014 4:51:16 GMT
Good evening everybody or Hello everybody, This time I dare to write something. Forgive me if I make some mistakes in English I am really French. On my opinion and according to the episodes I've watched on the french tv (france 3 on sunday evening) and also because Murdoch is Catholic and religious, I think he is a virgin. He seems to be more conservative than Julia. Of course I could be wrong. Bye. Bonjour! You are welcome here! Several people believe William is a virgin, and we love to argue over it! My friend who is a Catholic, though, does not believe religion would stand in his way. Could you explain more why being a Catholic would encourage William to remain a virgin? I think it is the fact that he was raised by Jesuits and if they provided any kind of sex education at all, it probably would have been heavy on the no premarital relations message. Keep youself pure, etc. He lived with them in is formative years and I think he took them at their word. Now that I've said that I will reprise a question I have had since I first saw The Murdoch Identity. He knew exactly what he was doing when he made a move on Anna and there wasn't the slightest hesitation. This raises questions among other things. Could his behavior be and indication of the way he behaved during the lost years that have been mentioned? He has always behaved more naturally with Anna than with Julia (until now, of course) So is that the real William Murdoch or is Toronto William the real one? Not sure that I haven't torpedoed my own argument, but it is something to think about. |
|
|
|
Post by Fallenbelle on Oct 19, 2014 5:03:30 GMT
Bonjour! You are welcome here! Several people believe William is a virgin, and we love to argue over it! My friend who is a Catholic, though, does not believe religion would stand in his way. Could you explain more why being a Catholic would encourage William to remain a virgin? I think it is the fact that he was raised by Jesuits and if they provided any kind of sex education at all, it probably would have been heavy on the no premarital relations message. Keep youself pure, etc. He lived with them in is formative years and I think he took them at their word. Now that I've said that I will reprise a question I have had since I first saw The Murdoch Identity. He knew exactly what he was doing when he made a move on Anna and there wasn't the slightest hesitation. This raises questions among other things. Could his behavior be and indication of the way he behaved during the lost years virgin Williamthat have been mentioned? He has always behaved more naturally with Anna than with Julia (until now, of course) So is that the real William Murdoch or is Toronto William the real one? Not sure that I haven't torpedoed my own argument, but it is something to think about. Yes-I totally agree! Toronto William is cautious and pious and would save himself for marriage-even if his sexual desires seep out despite his best efforts in inappropriate looking at Julia (especially) or other ladies ( to a lesser degree). But yes, TMI hints of a man with some experience. He's just too comfortable being the brash New Yorker named Harry. I like the idea of virgin!William, but I think there's some misspent youth lurking there. William's mentioned he hasn't drank in years (meaning he used to be a drinker) and serious, ambitious boys don't spend years at a logging camp. |
|
|
|
Post by snacky on Oct 19, 2014 5:05:08 GMT
I think it is the fact that he was raised by Jesuits and if they provided any kind of sex education at all, it probably would have been heavy on the no premarital relations message. Keep youself pure, etc. He lived with them in is formative years and I think he took them at their word. Where would I get more information on Jesuit education in the 19th century to establish this? Because eclair, who is nominally Catholic, doesn't see Catholicism as a barrier to sexual relations at all. His slick move with the corset does bespeak some sort of experience. |
|
|
|
Post by snacky on Oct 19, 2014 5:09:02 GMT
Yes-I totally agree! Toronto William is cautious and pious and would save himself for marriage-even if his sexual desires seep out despite his best efforts in inappropriate looking at Julia (especially) or other ladies ( to a lesser degree). But yes, TMI hints of a man with some experience. He's just too comfortable being the brash New Yorker named Harry. I like the idea of virgin!William, but I think there's some misspent youth lurking there. William's mentioned he hasn't drank in years (meaning he used to be a drinker) and serious, ambitious boys don't spend years at a logging camp. When does William say he "hasn't drank in years"? The logging camp is the obvious setting for a "misspent youth". But I still think William has always been prudent in some respect and he would have avoided STDs and the getting of children too early. I'm also really curious about whether Jesuit education really was super-ascetic. I don't think William would have slept with the "good girl" Liza - so he was "saving himself for marriage" from that point on. |
|
|
|
Post by Fallenbelle on Oct 19, 2014 5:19:23 GMT
Yes-I totally agree! Toronto William is cautious and pious and would save himself for marriage-even if his sexual desires seep out despite his best efforts in inappropriate looking at Julia (especially) or other ladies ( to a lesser degree). But yes, TMI hints of a man with some experience. He's just too comfortable being the brash New Yorker named Harry. I like the idea of virgin!William, but I think there's some misspent youth lurking there. William's mentioned he hasn't drank in years (meaning he used to be a drinker) and serious, ambitious boys don't spend years at a logging camp. When does William say he "hasn't drank in years"? The logging camp is the obvious setting for a "misspent youth". But I still think William has always been prudent in some respect and he would have avoided STDs and the getting of children too early. I'm also really curious about whether Jesuit education really was super-ascetic. I don't think William would have slept with the "good girl" Liza - so he was "saving himself for marriage" from that point on. Ooh, someone help me out here. I know I've heard it recently, but I can't remember it right now.  I've had Catholic friends and I agree Catholicism isn't good enough a reason. Piety would be, however, but the question is, has William always been as pious? Even Martin Luther had a profligate youth before he had a near-death experience that caused him to become an ascetic monk who just couldn't be pious enough before he made his realizations that turned Europe upside down. Plus, Didn't Eddie and William reminisce about getting in trouble as schoolboys? He wasn't always as serious as he is now. |
|
. If William is still a virgin, it surely will be mentioned, won't it? 
).
).
but play the game and just answer!
